Love Serve Lead, Inc. is hiring : SEO Strategist in Indianapolis

In a Nutshell

Valve+Meter is growing, and we’re looking for a results-driven SEO Strategist to join our performance marketing team. This is a hands-on role responsible for driving organic traffic, improving rankings, and increasing leads for a portfolio of clients operating in e-commerce, national or B2B markets.

We have offices in Indianapolis, Indiana and Denver, Colorado, but we are open to US-based candidates who prefer to work remotely. (We don’t currently operate in all 50 states, but we’d love to chat.) You will be expected to travel to Indianapolis for orientation and training your first week, and also at least two times per year for all team events.

You’ll lead the development and execution of technical, off-page, and on-page SEO strategies that align with each client’s business objectives and competitive landscape. Your work will go beyond ticking checkboxes—you’ll deliver impact.

Success in this role means launching insightful ThinkFirst strategies, executing high-leverage 90-day SEO plans, and ensuring continuous improvements in rankings, traffic, and goal completions from organic search.

SEO Strategists at Valve+Meter are accountable owners of their clients’ organic success. You’ll blend analysis, creativity, and executional muscle to prioritize initiatives that move the needle and make SEO a reliable revenue channel.

Why is this role important for Valve+Meter’s work?

Valve+Meter’s mission is built on results, not fluff. Our clients expect a measurable return on their marketing investments. That means using data, research, and executional excellence to turn search demand into business opportunity—at scale.

This role plays a key part in delivering that performance. You’ll collaborate with internal teams—content, development, paid media, design, analytics—and directly shape the SEO direction for each account. You’ll also contribute to the advancement of our SEO playbooks, tools, and frameworks.

Our best strategists are curious, assertive, and outcome-obsessed. They think like consultants, write like analysts, and operate with the ownership of a business leader.

Relevant Capabilities

Our Ideal Candidate should be able to :

Develop strategic, data-driven SEO roadmaps. Create ThinkFirst strategies that analyze competitive position, content gaps, search intent alignment, and technical health—turning these insights into prioritized plans tied to revenue outcomes.

Launch and manage 90-day SEO plans. Build quarterly cycles of work focused on the highest-leverage opportunities—whether content development, technical optimization, link building, or internal architecture improvements.

Own site-wide organic visibility. Focus on improving rankings for high-value, non-branded queries, increasing qualified sessions, and growing conversion rates from organic traffic.

Lead content strategy and optimization. Collaborate with content strategists and writers to plan, produce, and optimize content around core themes, service offerings, and customer pain points. This includes blogs, landing pages, and strategic pillar / sub-pillar structures.

Conduct technical SEO audits and partner on implementation. Identify and help resolve indexation issues, crawl problems, site architecture flaws, schema gaps, and other technical blockers.

Drive link acquisition strategy. Develop off-page strategies through guest posts, digital PR, niche edits, and authority-building collaborations that support ranking goals.

Monitor performance and translate data into decisions. Use tools like GA4, GSC, SEMrush, and Looker Studio to identify insights, measure campaign impact, and influence ongoing strategy.

Communicate strategy and results. Equip client-facing teams with reporting and messaging to explain what we’re doing, why it matters, and how it’s impacting business goals.

Work cross-functionally. Align SEO efforts with paid media, dev, analytics, and brand strategies—ensuring cohesive digital campaigns and resource-efficient execution.

Stay ahead of the curve. Monitor algorithm changes, industry shifts, and SERP trends. Test and share new techniques that improve performance.

What to Expect

When considering a new position, it is essential to understand what to expect from your day-to-day workflow and contribution expectations. At Valve+Meter, each subject matter expert has 5-7 key things they are primarily responsible for. The 5-7 things for this position encompass :

Managing a portfolio of SEO clients across multiple verticals.

Leading ThinkFirst strategy creation for new accounts.

Building and executing 90-day plans aligned to business goals and SERP opportunities.

Implementing on-page SEO changes, writing briefs, and partnering with internal teams.

Proactively identifying ranking challenges and search opportunities.

Reporting performance results and surfacing improvement areas.

Staying accountable for efficiency and utilization tied to company goals

Experience

Required :

Bachelor’s degree in marketing, business, or a related field, or equivalent professional experience

Minimum of 3 years experience in SEO, with a track record of excellent execution.

Mastery of SEO platforms : Google Search Console, GA4, Screaming Frog, SEMrush, Ahrefs, or similar.

Demonstrated ability to drive measurable improvements in organic rankings, traffic, and conversions.

Preferred :

5+ years of experience, especially in an agency or high-volume SEO environment.

Experience leading client strategy and reporting.

Background in content strategy, UX optimization, or CRO.

Experience with enterprise CMS platforms (e.g., WordPress, Webflow, HubSpot, etc.).

Skills

Deep knowledge of ranking factors, algorithm behavior, and modern SEO tactics.

Analytical mindset with strong Excel / Sheets and data interpretation ability.

Clear communicator—both written and verbal—with clients and internal teams.

Self-starter with strong project ownership and time management.

Highly organized, detail-oriented, and quality-obsessed.

Comfortable navigating ambiguity and balancing competing priorities.

Inquisitive and curious – you’re not a box-checker.

Love of data and numbers.

Fundamental knowledge of HTML would be fantastic.

What Valve+Meter Offers?

Valve+Meter is where you can solve diverse challenges for our clients and the organization alongside thoughtful, intelligent individuals who lead with a servant’s heart and a conviction to love others and be just. We encourage our team to bring their whole selves (and dogs) to work; we respect the need for work-life boundaries and allow for autonomy in your work and your career.

Medical, Dental, and Vision

401(k) Match

Company-Paid Life Insurance Policy

Three Weeks of Paid Time Off

Ten Paid Holidays

Two Paid Service Days

Flexible Work Environment

Casual Dress Code

Pet-Friendly Office

Environment for Fast Career Growth

Gym, Bike Share, Tenant Lounge onsite

About Us

We've named our practice Valve+Meter because the variables we can manage with you are the flow and cost of new business. The "valve" part of our approach manages the right rate of new business for your operation, and we set our pricing with you not based on the activities we pursue but on the "metered" results we generate.

Mission

We exist to change how businesses approach marketing by delivering abundance and accountability with a customer cost-per-acquisition strategy.

Vision

We inspire businesses to look at marketing as a revenue center rather than a cost center.

Core Values

Think : Focus. Find a way forward.

Love : Act in the long-term best interest of another.

Serve : Meet expectations. Go the extra mile.

Transform : Create dramatic change. Be irreplaceable.

Be Just : Be fair and transparent. Do no harm.

#J-18808-Ljbffr