Talent.com
T&H Realty Services, Inc
Property Manager Single-Family Rental PortfolioT&H Realty Services, Inc • Indianapolis, IN, United States
Property Manager Single-Family Rental Portfolio

Property Manager Single-Family Rental Portfolio

T&H Realty Services, Inc • Indianapolis, IN, United States
5 days ago
Salary
$55,000.00 yearly
Job type
  • Full-time
Job description

Single-Family Portfolio Property Manager

T&H Realty Services is seeking an experienced Single-Family Portfolio Property Manager to oversee a portfolio of approximately 350450 scattered-site residential homes throughout the Indianapolis market.

This is not an on-site multifamily role.

This position focuses on portfolio oversight, owner communication, turnover coordination, and cross-functional execution, serving as the primary point of contact for property owners and partnering with resident relations, leasing, maintenance, accounting, and field teams to drive portfolio performance.

If you have experience managing single-family rental portfolios and enjoy balancing owner relationships with operational execution, this may be the right next step.

We hire for this role regularly. While we may not have an immediate opening today, we're always interested in connecting with experienced candidates for upcoming opportunities.

What This Role Looks Like

You will manage your portfolio from a strategic and communication-driven perspective. You are not in the field but you are deeply connected to what is happening across your homes.

Your focus includes:

  • Serving as the primary point of contact for property owners
  • Advising owners on turnover scope, performance, and property decisions
  • Coordinating approvals and funding for turnovers and large work orders
  • Overseeing security deposit finalizations and documentation
  • Managing escalations with professionalism and accountability
  • Monitoring aged inventory
  • Partnering closely with resident relations, maintenance, leasing, accounting, and field evaluators
  • Ensuring clear, proactive communication across all stakeholders

This is a portfolio-based role requiring prioritization, ownership, and strong communication skills.

Required Experience

To be considered, candidates should have:

  • 3+ years of direct single-family rental property management experience
  • Experience managing a portfolio of 350+ scattered-site homes preferred
  • Experience serving as the primary contact for property owners or investors
  • Strong understanding of turnovers, security deposit reconciliations, and vendor coordination
  • Comfort managing high email and communication volume
  • Experience using property management software (AppFolio, Rentvine, Yardi, etc.)

Multifamily-only experience without exposure to a single-family portfolio may not be considered.

Who Thrives in This Role

  • Highly organized professionals who manage by priority, not panic
  • Clear communicators who can explain decisions confidently to owners
  • Individuals who enjoy autonomy and accountability
  • Problem-solvers who anticipate issues instead of reacting to them
  • Professionals who prefer coordination and strategy over constant fieldwork

Compensation & Schedule

  • Salary range: $55,000$65,000 (based on experience)
  • Performance-based year-end bonus potential
  • Spot recognition bonuses throughout the year
  • MondayFriday, 8:30 AM 5:00 PM
  • Hybrid schedule (12 days in office, remainder remote)
  • Full benefits package

Why T&H Realty Services

  • Established, locally respected property management firm
  • Smaller company culture with strong cross-team collaboration
  • Defined processes with room for professional input and improvement
  • Focused portfolio model with departmental support structure

You will not be just another manager in a 60,000-home operation. Your portfolio matters here and so does your voice.

Apply with resume and salary requirements.

T&H Realty Services is an Equal Opportunity Employer. Learn more at

Create a job alert for this search

Property Manager Single-Family Rental Portfolio • Indianapolis, IN, United States

Similar jobs

Registered Representative - State Farm Agent Team Member

Matt Kwiatkowski - State Farm AgentFranklin, IN, United States
Full-time

Do you want a career and not just a job?.We are a very busy office and are looking for our next great team member.We are a growing agency with big dreams and lots of potential.We are an established... Show more

 • Promoted

Veterinary Business Partner

PetfolkFishers, IN, United States
Full-time

Veterinary Business Partner - Future Opportunities!.At Petfolk, we're reshaping veterinary care by blending high-quality medicine with a welcoming, connected experience for pets, their families, an... Show more

 • Promoted

Asset Manager - Stabilized

CREA, LLCIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

CREA, LLC is a full-service low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) syndicator forming long-term relationships with investors and developers that cultivate success and improve lives.With more than 25... Show more

 • Promoted

Financial Center Manager Associate

Fifth Third BancorpCarmel, IN, United States
Full-time

Financial Center Manager Associate.Make banking a Fifth Third better We connect great people to great opportunities.Are you ready to take the next step? Discover a career in banking at Fifth Third ... Show more

 • Promoted

Property Manager

SHP Management Corp.Indianapolis, IN, United States
Temporary

The Property Manager oversees all functions of the property, including supervision of staff, handling tenant communications, performing annual certifications, TRACS submission, NSPIRE inspection pr... Show more

 • Promoted

National MedSpa Sales Manager Traveling Position

Dermafix SpaCarmel, IN, United States
Full-time

National MedSpa Sales Manager Traveling Position.Are you a high-performing sales leader with a strong ability to drive revenue, lead teams, and sell premium services? We're hiring a Senior Travel ... Show more

 • Promoted

Senior Indirect Commodity Manager

Masco CorporationIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

Job Title: Senior Commodity Manager.At Delta Faucet, we are committed to transforming everyday experiences with water through innovative products and exceptional service.As a leader in the plumbing... Show more

 • Promoted

General Manager

Prime Car WashWestfield, IN, United States
Full-time

At Prime Car Wash, you are taking the first step towards a very rewarding career.At Prime Car Wash, we promote personal and professional growth, encourage individuality, and truly value our employe... Show more

 • Promoted

Senior Indirect Commodity Manager

MascoIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

At Delta Faucet, we are committed to transforming everyday experiences with water through innovative products and exceptional service.As a leader in the plumbing industry, we take pride in our dedi... Show more

 • Promoted

Automotive Finance Manager

Kia of FishersFishers, IN, United States
Full-time

Automotive Finance & Insurance Manager.The Ed Napleton Automotive Group is looking for our next Automotive Finance & Insurance Manager.This is an exciting opportunity in a growing, fast-paced indus... Show more

 • Promoted

Manager - Unclaimed Property

CyfleIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

We have partnered with a large law firm to provide them with a Manager - Unclaimed Property.Please review the below description and let us know if you are interested.Candidate can work in any of th... Show more

 • Promoted

Wealth Manager - Real Estate Investment ( Remote )

Bayut & DubizzleIndianapolis, IN, United States
Remote
Full-time

Wealth ManagerBayut & dubizzle have the unique distinction of being iconic, homegrown brands with a strong presence across the seven emirates in the UAE.Connecting millions of users across the ... Show more

 • Promoted

REMOTE Sr. Foreclosure Specialist (7:00 A.M or 7:30 A.M to 4:00 P.M PST)

Carrington Holding Company, LLCWestfield, IN, United States
Remote
Full-time

Come join our amazing team and work remote from home! Work schedule: Monday through Friday from 7:00 A.Foreclosure Specialist will be responsible for monitoring vendor activities during the process... Show more

 • Promoted

Assistant Property Manager - The Wren

Pedcor InvestmentsCarmel, IN, United States
Full-time

Do you thrive in the energy of a fast-moving environment where every day brings something new and you're the one making it all happen?.If that sounds like you, The Wren is looking for a driven, peo... Show more

 • Promoted

Property Manager

CYM LivingIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

CYM Living - Where caring meets innovation.We are a national real estate firm with corporate headquarters in Chicago, IL, and just outside of New York City.Our mission is to provide our residents w... Show more

 • Promoted

Director/VP of Property Management - Multifamily

Kingsley-Rose Executive SearchIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

Director / VP of Property Management.A growing owner-operator is bringing property management in-house and seeking a high-impact Director or VP of Property Management to build and lead the platform... Show more

 • Promoted

Automotive Finance Manager

Napletons Arlington Heights Chrysler Dodge Jeep RamFishers, IN, United States
Full-time

Automotive Finance & Insurance Manager.The Ed Napleton Automotive Group is looking for our next Automotive Finance & Insurance Manager.This is an exciting opportunity in a growing, fast-paced indus... Show more

 • Promoted

Managing Director, Real Estate Valuation

BDO USAIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

Valuation & Capital Market Analysis Managing Director.The Valuation & Capital Market Analysis Managing Director is responsible for leading, executing and delivery of challenging valuation engagemen... Show more

 • Promoted

Tax Manager | Real Estate

CBIZIndianapolis, IN, United States
Full-time

Essential Functions and Primary Duties.Serve as client's trusted advisor, demonstrates knowledge of industry trends, identify client issues and conflicts; proactively communicate solution options t... Show more

 • Promoted

Manager, FP&A

Heartland Food Products GroupCarmel, IN, United States
Full-time

Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) Leader.We are seeking a strategic, commercially minded FP&A leader/team member to help drive financial analysis & planning, performance management, and decision... Show more